Carlson Post 8: Searching for the ‘H’ in ‘DH’

This week I found myself feeling somewhat resistant to Wolfgang Ernst’s “Media Archaeography: Method and Machine Versus History and Narrative of Media.” While this might just be the humanist within me talking, I am still a bit uncomfortable with the idea of completely separate the technological from the human. Ernst is immediately critical of what he calls “media stories,” writing:

“The cultural inclination to give sense to data through narrative structure is not easy for human subjectivity to overcome. It takes machines to temporarily liberate us from such limitations. Technology, according to Martin Heidegger, is more than instrumental; it transcends the human.” (Ernst 56)

While it may simply be a matter of personal opinion, I find these “media stories” to be one of the most fascinating aspects of technology. When we went to the Media Archaeology Lab as a class a few weeks ago, I continually found myself pondering the narratives of the machines in the hands of their previous owners. What physical properties could Kirschenbaum find on the micro-level of each computer and what could we learn about its story? As technology becomes a more and more dominating aspect of the human experience, I think these “media stories” become more and more important.

Personal opinions aside, I have to wonder how this separation of the technological from the human fits into the definition of Digital Humanities (a definition that we have yet to nail down but that I continue to struggle with). If we want to remove the human, does Ernst’s theoretical framework still count as Digital Humanities? It seems to me that we might have to remove the H from DH in this instance.

Screen Shot 2015-10-25 at 7.28.18 PMErnst uses the example of the Milman Parry Collection of Oral Literature, writing that “Parry . . . went to Serbia and Montenegro to conduct a study in experimental philology, recording epic songs to discover how epics as long as Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey have been transmitted in culture without writing” (60). I found the collection online and was able to listen to a few recordings. Despite the fact that I was unable to understand what was being said and sung in the recordings, I still felt resistance to Ernst’s theory. Ernst writes that “the media-archaeological ear listens to radio in an extreme way: listening to the noise of the transmitting system itself” (68). Even when listening to recordings in a foreign language, I don’t find myself interested in the static created by the recording device. I listen to these recordings searching for information about the people of Serbia and Montenegro; I can’t shake my interest in the human here.

Works Cited

Ernst, Wolfgang. 2011. “Media Archaeography: Method and Machine Versus History and Narrative of Media.”

2 thoughts on “Carlson Post 8: Searching for the ‘H’ in ‘DH’

  1. ebcousins says:

    I felt similarly reluctant to let go of narrative…I’m curious for us to talk in class about what might be the benefits / losses in shifting away from narrative, and if narrative is tied inherently to the human (and vice versa) or if there are other valuable ways of communicating / focusing our work that might be worth exploring. That being said, I’m with you in that humanities seems almost inextricable from narrative. If narrative isn’t what we do, what is? <—-in no way a sarcastic or rhetorical question. Is narrative a required building block for humanities projects?


  2. rjones2155 says:

    I’m also concerned about the term “liberate”. What type of freedoms do we gain when we lose narrative and human stories? Who are we ignoring? What types of histories should be included that may be forgotten? I sometimes wonder if I’ve taken my own reading of Ernst too far, but I’m still curious what is lost when we only read the surfaces of materials.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: